Invasive Species: Fact or Fiction


It seems the hot topic in the last few years has been the invasion of non-native species of aquatic plants and fish into Lake Champlain.  To quote the Lake Champlain Basin Program Guide for Aquatic Invasive Species: “The Lake Champlain Basin is home to a number of invasive species that cause economic and ecological harm to our ecosystem”.

I have to ask: what harm?  Yes, it is costly to try and rid the eco- system of a harmful species once it’s established but then what harm is the species causing? Where is the peer reviewed research and long term studies? Just to state non-native species harmful or will compete within the existing food chain without some documentation doesn’t seem very scientific. Actually, it seems very irresponsible.

Eurasian Watermilfoil is the most commonly named invasive plant species in Lake Champlain. I am sure milfoil causes problems with the million dollar waterfront houses’ water intake systems or the use of Jet Skis in the shallow flats from the heavy growth.  But then again it seems from my years of fishing that where the milfoil grows so does the best fishing occur. Ask any big time Pro and he will always say” find the milfoil find the bass.”  Where are the studies by the scientific community comparing the quality of fishing before the milfoil entered the Lake.  I remember when 12lbs was a great catch in the 1980’s now if you don’t catch 20 plus pounds it has been a slow day. I contend the increase in the quality of fishing is because of the milfoil.  Yes, it causes problems in some smaller shallower lakes but that can be controlled, but it does cost money. Money land owners don’t want to spend.

A recent survey by Bassmaster Magazine named Lake Champlain one of the top five bass lakes in the USA, probably wouldn’t have occurred if Milfoil hadn’t invaded the Lake. One has to pick their poison: the economic benefit of a great fishery or no weeds and no fish. I have witnessed the TVA in the south spend millions of dollars treating the lakes of the south to kill milfoil and hydrilla to protect the million dollar lake front properties and megawatt hydro-electric plants, and wind up with a limited fish population. Case in point, Fort Loudon Lake in east Tennessee, during the years the lake was polluted with milfoil and hydrilla the bass population thrived, today no weeds and no fish. One can fish all day and maybe get five bites, compared to Lake Champlain where it five bass in five minutes.

Mark Malchoff of the Lake Champlain Sea Grant  spoke before the Essex County Board of Supervisors concerning  the possibility of the the invasion of other species he finds disturbing namely hydrilla and the round goby. He gave his opinion that they could cause “economic havoc”. Please bring on the havoc! I recently returned from fishing on the western basin of Lake Ontario, an area filled with hydrilla, milfoil and round gobies. Believe me the bass are bigger and more plentiful than in Lake Champlain. There are far more 20 pound sacks of smallmouth brought to the scales by the same pro fisherman who compete on Lake Champlain.  And it’s strange that not once did I encounter any Spiny Waterfleas.

Before you get up in arms about invasive species here are some facts. Brown trout and Rainbows are a non-native species stocked by the DEC. Lake trout are not natural to the Lake and the common carp has been here my entire life. In fact until a few years ago if you bought a fish sandwich at McDonalds it was probably made with common carp meat. There are pluses and minuses to every situation, before we throw out the bath water let’s make sure the baby isn’t in the tub.

I really tire of the politicians wanting their names in the press by taking a stand that seems popular without the real facts. This great country was developed from all forms of invasions; maybe some of these aquatic creatures are just the ones that will improve the fishery.


2 Responses to Invasive Species: Fact or Fiction

  1. Garsto Grittney says:

    I love the Water Chestnuts for fishing. The milfoil is fine if dont mind a little snagging but if you want fish fish where the fish are and thats in the nuts and foil…..

  2. Garsto Grittney says:

    PS: Foil and Nuts are top water at its best and just coming into Prime Time! Long time fishing Benson Landing southward

Leave a Reply